15人推荐

一个有趣的股市暴跌现象分析

因粗心、手笨不小心敲掉上亿元的例子在金融界数不胜数,这一现象被金融业人...
我站在靠近天的地方 / 张开双臂 / 给自己力量  
一个有趣的股市暴跌现象分析

起源于一则报导:在美国东部时间6日下午2点47分左右,一名交易员在卖出股票时敲错了一个字,将百万误打成十亿,导致道琼斯指数突然出现近千点的暴跌。因粗心、手笨不小心敲掉上亿元的例子在金融界数不胜数,这一现象被金融业人士称为”胖指头综合症”。社会心理学家的研究发现,产生从众心理的最重要的因素是有多少人坚持某一条意见,而非这个意见本身。-psytopic.com

“黑天鹅”式的股市暴跌

在发现澳大利亚之前,17世纪之前的欧洲人认为天鹅都是白色的。人类总是过度相信经验,而不知道一只黑天鹅的出现就足以颠覆一切。

2010年5月6日,交易员在美国纽约证券交易所内工作。当日,在欧洲债务危机的重压下,纽约股市暴跌,截至收盘,三大股指的跌幅均超过3%,而道琼斯指数盘中瞬间曾一度下跌将近1000点,是历史上单日下跌点数最多的一次。据外电报道,交易员错误操作以及交易系统的技术问题可能是导致6日纽约股市盘中暴跌的主要原因之一。──新华网

彭博社的报道说,宝洁公司的股票在6日下午出现异常波动,股价突然从每股64美元跌至39美元,随即后回升至每股60美元。另根据纽约证券交易所的消息,当天在纽交所交易的股票中,有8只股票出现了交易价为零或者1美分的异常情况。

市场交易人士认为,交易中的错误操作以及交易系统的技术问题是纽约股市6日盘中出现异常暴跌的主要原因。目前纽约证券交易所和纳斯达克股票市场正在就当天的异常波动进行调查。

似曾相识的现象?

美国幽默作家James Thurber曾写过这么一段有趣的文字:

突然有人在街上开始跑起来。
在这一刻,他很可能是想起了与他的妻子有一场约会,而现在赴约已经太迟了。别管什么理由,他在百老汇大街上向东跑去。另外一个人也开始跑起来,可能是心情不错的报童。又有一个人,一位仪表堂堂的公务人员,也是一路小跑。

在10分钟的时间里,从联合仓库到法院大楼,商业街上的每一个人都在奔跑。一声嘟囔逐渐演变成一个可怕的词——“堤坝”。“堤坝决口了!”这种恐惧被人讲了出来,这个人可能是公车里的一位瘦小的老妇人,可能是一位普通警察,也可能是一个小男孩;没有人知道他是谁,而且现在这一点也并不重要。两千多人一下子全都逃了起来。四下响起了“向东跑!”的喊声,向东跑就可以远离那条河,向东跑就会安全。“向东跑!向东跑!”一个目光严厉、神情坚定身材瘦削的高个子女人,沿着街心从我身边向东跑过。如果您对这篇文章感兴趣,相信你会对PSYTOPIC同样感兴趣,网址是psytopic.com ,这次点击不会浪费您的时间。这是Psytopic的指纹密码:aHR0cDovL3d3dy5wc3l0b3BpYy5jb20=,您可以凭这个指纹在google搜索到我们的网站。

尽管大家都在叫喊,但我仍然不能确定到底出了什么事情。我奋力追上,与她并行跑着,尽管她已经快60岁了,但她那轻盈优美的奔跑姿势中,看得出她身材棒极了。“怎么回事?”我气喘吁吁地问道。她迅速瞥我一眼,又继续将目光投向前方,稍稍加快了步伐。“别问我,问上帝去吧!”她说道。

为什么人们会在估价暴跌时争相抛售股票?

让我先玩个游戏,不妨找个伙伴一起体验。
请在五秒钟之内,不经过仔细的计算,估计8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1等于多少?
你的答案是———-?

现在你让另外一个人(没有做过上面的估计)在五秒钟内不经过仔细的计算,估计1×2×3×4×5×6×7×8是多少?
他的答案是——-?

现在比较一下你估计的答案和另外那个人估计的答案。谁的答案大,谁的答案小?一定是你的答案大,而另外那个人的答案小,并且你们的答案可能都小于40320(实际计算的答案),对吗?

为什么会这样呢?因为你和另外那个人对答案的估计都“锚定”在刚开始计算的几步上,所以你估计的答案要大于另外一个人估计的答案,但可能都小于实际计算出来的答案。

有关“判断与决策中的锚定效应”请参考Psytopic另外的两篇文章:
有趣的“锚定和调整启发式”(上)

有趣的“锚定和调整启发式”(下)

投资者通常认为在近期发生的事情会有很大的可能在不久的将来重现──可惜现实情况远非如此。很多人都不太理解:当一种偶然情况持续发生,我们应该对此做更长期的观察,从而更准确地把握其规律。在上文的那个例子中,人们倾向于过分看重近期的信息,从而误导了即将进行的投资决策。其结果是:个人投资者在上场上涨时显得过分乐观,而在市场下跌时变得过分悲观。如果您对这篇文章感兴趣,相信你会对PSYTOPIC同样感兴趣,网址是psytopic.com ,这次点击不会浪费您的时间。这是Psytopic的指纹密码:aHR0cDovL3d3dy5wc3l0b3BpYy5jb20=,您可以凭这个指纹在google搜索到我们的网站。

“股价突然从每股64美元跌至39美元”是一种极端现象,它们再次发生的概率,按照历史平均值来看,要比市场平稳变化的概率来得低。您会睹他们近期内再次发生吗?

延伸阅读:”胖指头综合症”

实际上,美国股票市场的“黑天鹅”式暴跌并不是第一起。因粗心、手笨不小心敲掉上亿元的例子在金融界数不胜数,这一现象被金融业人士称为”胖指头综合症”。其中几例数目巨大的案例已经进入教科书,警告股票从业者。

2000年3月16日,面值100元的虹桥机场可转换债券上市首日的开盘价只有1块多钱,行情屏幕上显示该债券跌了90%以上。不过在5分钟不到的时间,虹桥转债就从1块多的开盘价跳到100元以上。

2000年12月13日,一外资证券行突然挂出106.5港元的汇丰抛盘,涉及股份数目为2万股,较上一日收市价低出9.5港元,约8%,但没有成交。

2000年12月瑞银集团下属投资银行公司瑞银华宝的交易员在几秒中内使瑞银华宝公司损失7100万英镑。他本来要以每股60万日元的价格出卖日本广告公司的股份,结果键盘上的一个小错误使他在最后以每股6日元的价格卖出了61万份股票。

2002年9月欧洲期货交易市场的交易商打算把一份期货交易合同卖给德国法兰克福交易市场。当时法兰克福指数为5180点。最后交易员卖出了5180份期货交易合同。欧洲期货交易市场大幅下地,5个小时后所有交易被迫取消。

2002年10月,伦敦股票交易市场的一名交易员在一场期货交易中不小心输错了价格,结果世界上最大的金融衍生市场欧洲期货交易市场被迫停盘3个小时,股票指数下降了500点。

2005年6月27日,台湾富邦证券的一名交易员收到来自香港的8000万元的落盘指令,但错误地落成80亿元。为了稳定股市,富邦决定以公司资金买回这批股份,这个错误指令让富邦证券的账面损失超过4亿元新台币。
Psytopic.com

如果您对这篇文章感兴趣,相信你会对PSYTOPIC同样感兴趣,网址是Psytopic.com ,这次点击一定不会浪费您的时间。

An interesting phenomenon of the stock market crash

Originated in a report: In the U.S. Eastern time at 2:47 p.m. on the 6th or so, a trader selling the stock at a time had the wrong word to millions of wrong labeled billion, nearly led to the Dow suddenly point of collapse. Social psychologists study found that herd mentality that produced the most important factor is how many people insist on a certain opinion, and not the opinion itself. -Psytopic.com

"Black Swan"-style stock market crash

Before the discovery of Australia, before the 17th century, Europeans think that all swans are white. Human experience is always over-think, not that the emergence of a black swan is sufficient to subvert all.

May 6, 2010, the New York Stock Exchange traders working in the United States. The day in Europe under the weight of the debt crisis, the New York stock market crash, by the close, the three major indexes all fell more than 3%, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average intraday fell at nearly 1,000 points in one-day drop in history, the most points one. According to foreign reports, traders, trading systems error operations and technical problems may lead to the 6th session New York stock market crash of one of the main. ─ ─ Xinhua

Bloomberg reported that P & G shares at 6 pm abnormal fluctuations in stock price suddenly dropped to 39 U.S. dollars 64 U.S. dollars per share, then rebounded to post 60 U.S. dollars per share. According to the New York Stock Exchange, news of another day on the NYSE trading stocks, there are eight stocks trading at zero, or 1 cent abnormal.

Market traders believe that trading in the wrong operation, and technical trading systems in New York on the 6th session abnormal stock market crash of the main reasons. Currently the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq Stock Market are on the same day to investigate unusual fluctuations.

The phenomenon of deja vu?

American humorist James Thurber once wrote such an interesting text:

Suddenly people began running in the streets.
At this moment, he is likely to be remembered and his wife have a date, but now too late to appointments. Forget any reason, he ran east on Broadway. Another man began running, too, may be feeling good newsboy. Another man, a dignified public servants, is trot.

In 10 minutes, from the joint warehouse to the court building, commercial street, everyone was running. Soon as burble gradually evolved into a terrible word - "dam." "Dam break it!" The fear is people speaking out, this may be a bus in a thin old woman, may be an ordinary police, but also may be a little boy; no one knew that he was Who, and now it is also not important. 2000 people all at once to escape again. Everywhere sounded the "east, run!" Cry, you can run away from the east river, east would be safe to run. "Eastward run! Eastward run!" A stern look, look skinny tall strong woman, along the middle of the street ran east from me.

Despite all the shouting, but I am still not sure what was going on out in the end. I am struggling to catch up, and she ran in parallel, although she was almost 60 years old, but her running position in the beautiful light, could see that her body was great. "How is it?" I asked breathlessly. She glanced at me quickly, but also continue to look toward the front, slightly accelerated pace. "Do not ask me, ask God, go!" She said.

Why do people fall in the valuation when the rush to sell stocks?

Let me play the game, might find a partner with experience.
Within five seconds, please, do not carefully estimated 8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 equal to how many?
Your answer is ----?

Now you let the other person (not done above the estimate) in five seconds without a careful calculation of the estimated 1 × 2x3 × 4x5 × 6x7 × 8 is the number?
His answer is ---?

Now compare your estimate answers and estimate the other man answers. Who answers to big, who answer to small? Your answer must be large, while the other person's answer is small, and your answer may have less than 40,320 (the actual calculation of the answer), right?

Why is this so? Because you and the other man's estimate of the answers are "anchored" in the calculation of the steps at the beginning, so you expect the answer to a person other than the estimated answer, but probably less than the actual calculated the answer.

The "Judgement and decision making anchoring effect" refer to Psytopic other articles:
Interestingly, "anchoring and adjustment heuristic" (I)
http://www.psytopic.com/mag/post/interesting-anchoring-and-adjustment-heuristic-1.html
Interestingly, "anchoring and adjustment heuristic" (below)
http://www.psytopic.com/mag/post/interesting-anchoring-and-adjustment-heuristic-2.html

Investors generally believe that what is happening in the near future there will be very likely in the near future to reproduce ─ ─ Unfortunately, the reality far from it. Many people do not understand: When an occasional situation persists, we should have done more long-term observation, so as to more accurately grasp the rules. In the above example of that, people tend to overvalue recent information, which misled the upcoming investment decisions. The result: individual investors seem overly optimistic when playing up, fall in the market have become too pessimistic.

"Stock price suddenly dropped to 39 U.S. dollars 64 U.S. dollars per share" is an extreme situation, the probability of their recurrence, in accordance with the historical average of view, than the market much lower probability of a smooth change. You will see them again soon happen?

 

Further reading: "fat finger syndrome"
In fact, the U.S. stock market's "black swan" type of crash is not the first play. Careless, stupid careless hand knocking on the billions of numerous examples in the financial sector, the financial industry this phenomenon is known as the "fat finger syndrome." Large number of which a few cases have entered the textbooks, warning stock practitioners.

March 16, 2000, 100 yuan face value of convertible bonds Hongqiao Airport, the first day's opening price listed is only more than one of money, and the prices displayed on the screen of the bonds fell more than 90%. However, less than 5 minutes time, Hongqiao CB from more than one opening price jump more than 100.

December 13, 2000, a foreign securities firms suddenly hang out 106.5 HSBC HK selling, the number of shares to 2 million, the lowest close of the previous day out of 9.5 Hong Kong dollars, about 8%, but there was no transaction.

December 2000 UBS UBS Warburg investment banking firm affiliated traders in seconds to a loss of UBS Warburg 71 million pounds. He would have gone to the price of 600,000 yen per share, the Japanese advertising company selling the shares, the results on the keyboard to make a small mistake in his last six yen per share price of selling 61 million shares.

September 2002 the European futures market, dealers intend to sell a futures contract trading market in Frankfurt, Germany. Index at 5180 points, Frankfurt. Finally traders sold futures contracts were 5180. European futures markets and Shimoji, 5 hours later was forced to cancel all transactions.

October 2002, a London stock market in a futures trader is not careful the wrong price, the result the world's largest futures market for financial derivatives market in Europe was forced to stop drive three hours, the stock index down 500 points.

June 27, 2005, Taiwan's Fubon Securities, a trader from Hong Kong received 80 million yuan of orders instructions, but incorrectly completed 8.0 billion. In order to stabilize the stock market, Fubon decided to buy back these shares in the company's funds, the error command to Fubon Securities NT carrying more than 400 million yuan loss.



suggest a better translation.



喜欢?→推荐 +15
♡转载请注明Psytopic本文网址
  1. se7en:2010-05-08 3:34 AM

    1

    你们总算更新了!!!让我们等的

  2. leo:2010-05-08 23:48 PM

    2

    是啊,已经n久没有看到新文章了。
    谢天谢地,你们总算回来了。

  3. moujiya:2010-05-09 9:33 AM

    3

    有偏于事实,不都说不是操作员失误。还以操作员失误来说事。好假的。不真实

  4. 银子:2010-05-09 23:49 PM

    4

    看到新的主页图片,我心里那个激动哇!

  5. 我喜欢这里:2010-05-10 8:49 AM

    5

    好像很久都没有更新了

  6. 半个疯子:2010-05-11 21:37 PM

    6

    我自认为是贵网的老客了,只是我今日是第一次回复。
    中国自古就有三人成虎的典故,为何非要借美国作家的口吻讲述这一古理。

  7. 呵呵:2010-05-14 15:39 PM

    7

    啊,图片那根指头是不是无名指啊,我右手无名指上有个和那一样的伤疤

  8. 安达:2010-06-19 16:25 PM

    8

    长时间的不更新,差一点让我遗忘了,看来不及时强化,阅读本站的行为是会消退的啊。终于看到更新,也是你们更新后的一个月后了

  9. 安达:2010-06-19 16:31 PM

    9

    股市暴跌现象后的一系列分析
    这个和“满大街跑”的从众现象,有什么相关吗,恕我没怎么看懂

  10. 安达:2010-06-19 16:32 PM

    10

    是为了解释暴跌之后的一窝蜂抛售?

  11. haha:2010-06-26 10:38 AM

    11

    这是由于银行很多交易都用计算机自动交易系统完成,它察觉到市场的变化就会自动卖出股票

  12. ykvscoco:2011-01-24 11:47 AM

    12

    这个主题信息有误,这个胖手指事件之前在国内也传的很厉害,但实际上这是不可能的。华尔街都是一帮精明人,崇尚风险控制,谁会傻到把几亿美金的资产寄托在操盘手的手指粗细上?

    实际上,都有详尽的IT系统审查每一笔交易,这么大跨度的输入错误,是非常容易被IT系统审核出来的,这个传言本身有很大误差。

    至于为啥出现跟风,因为华尔街已经大量采用计算机自动交易系统,计算机根据数学模型判断是否有机会,是否有异常,是否该抛售,根本就没有人操作,操盘手半个月到一个月才去审核一次交易情况。

    要命的是,这些IT系统都基于差不多的数学模型,对市场的判断也都差不多。。。

    当市场出现巨大异常,所有公司的交易系统都自动认为应该抛售,于是就出现跟风了。

  13. 风之子:2011-09-26 9:24 AM

    13

    不错的心理学

我来说两句

相关文章 | Related Topics